Michigan's school pension isn't fully funded yet. It might be by 2030.
The Governor announced that MPSERS, the pension for more than 400,000 current and retired school employees, is “Fully Funded Ahead of Schedule.” We checked each claim against the state's own reports. Most of the numbers hold up. The headline doesn't, and the 2030 date is a forecast the state's consultant first made (as 2031) in January 2025.
For Troy School District
About $14.8 million a year of Troy's pension bill is the debt charge that ends at payoff, if the state lets districts keep the savings. That would not happen before the 2030–31 school year. See what it means for Troy.Independent analysis · last updated Nov. 18, 2026 · every figure links to a public source
What holds up, and what doesn't
Quotes are from the Governor's release. Findings come from MPSERS's actuarial valuations, its annual report, and the State of Michigan Investment Board's own materials.
Michigan Public School Pension System Fully Funded Ahead of Schedule(headline)
on track to reach full funding by 2030, rather than its previously projected date under current law of 2038
reduce future pension costs by approximately $3.2 billion annually, with about $1.5B from the state and $1.7B from districts
In Fiscal Year 2026, the state earned a 14% return … a 10-year annualized return of 10.7%, exceeding the 9.5% median
years of disciplined pension contributions … above what is called for in the current statute
MPSERS' retiree healthcare benefits reached fully funded status in 2023
$15.7 billion in state-level contributions … total contributions have reached $43.7 billion
Up from about 60% to 74.6% in ten years
“Funded” means assets divided by the benefits already earned. The official figure uses a five-year smoothed asset value, so good and bad years phase in gradually. On Sept. 30, 2025, smoothed assets were 94% of market value, so gains are still waiting to be counted.
Show as a table
| Sept. 30 | Funded | Sept. 30 | Funded |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2015 | 60.5% | 2021 | 64.1% |
| 2016 | 59.7% | 2022 | 64.3% |
| 2017 | 61.6% | 2023 | 68.8% |
| 2018 | 60.7% | 2024 | 71.2% |
| 2019 | 60.4% | 2025 | 74.6% |
| 2020 | 60.9% |
Where it might be now
The official count for Sept. 30, 2026 won't come until the next valuation (last year's was issued March 3). We made a rough estimate from published figures: about 88% at market value. Closing the remaining gap of about $11 billion by 2030 needs returns somewhat above the plan's 6% assumption, with the debt payment held near $3.2 billion a year.
Our back-of-envelope (not an official figure)
- Start: market-value assets of $78.66B (MPSERS ACFR, Sept. 30, 2025) and liabilities of $98.80B (2025 valuation).
- FY2026: assets earn the release's 14%; cash flow repeats FY2025's (contributions $4.90B in, benefits and expenses $5.83B out). Liabilities grow at the 6% assumption, plus normal cost (13.79% of $9.80B payroll), minus benefits.
- Result: about $88.7B against $100.1B, or about 88.6%, with a gap of about $11.4B. The real figure will differ: MPSERS's own FY2026 return and cash flows aren't published yet.
- Rolled forward with the debt payment at $3.19B a year: at 6% returns, 100% arrives in about FY2031; at 7.5% a year, about FY2029; at 4% a year, not by 2035.
The forecast has always had a wide range
Treasury's January 2025 asset-liability study (by Aon) projected the funded ratio thousands of times under different market paths. Its central case reached 100% in fiscal 2031. The spread shows how much depends on markets.
| Market-value funded ratio | 2028 | 2033 | 2043 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bad markets (5th percentile) | 58% | 59% | 69% |
| Below average (25th) | 75% | 85% | 108% |
| Central case (median) | 89% | 108% | 154% |
| Above average (75th) | 103% | 134% | >200% |
| Good markets (95th) | 126% | 185% | >200% |
| Chance of being over 100% | 31% | 58% | 79% |
Source: Aon, MPSERS Asset-Liability Study, January 2025, p. 28 (Treasury's proposed mix, 77% return-seeking; the mix then in place gave nearly identical medians of 90%, 108% and 157%). It assumes a 6.00% discount rate and actual returns through March 31, 2024. It started from 67%; strong returns since then have improved the starting point.
Why it's paying off early: a floor on the debt payment
Each year the actuaries compute a payment toward the unfunded liability. Strong returns have pushed that number down. But laws passed in 2017 and 2018 (PA 92 of 2017, PA 181 of 2018) say the payment can't fall below the prior year's, in dollars, “until such time as the UAAL is ‘paid off.’” PA 127 of 2024 reset that floor to the FY2025 amount. Paying more than the formula asks is what pulls the payoff date forward.
Show as a table
| State fiscal year | Computed debt payment | Normal cost (continues) | Set by valuation of |
|---|---|---|---|
| FY2025 | $3.187B | $0.689B | Sept. 30, 2022 |
| FY2026 | $2.972B | $0.802B | Sept. 30, 2023 |
| FY2027 | $2.882B | $0.803B | Sept. 30, 2024 |
| FY2028 | $2.685B | $0.828B | Sept. 30, 2025 |
What stops at full funding
The debt payment, about $3.2 billion a year. The release splits it as about $1.5B from the state (through School Aid Section 147c) and about $1.7B from districts. Since FY2026, a district's debt-payment rate is capped at 15.21% of payroll, down from 20.96% (PA 127 of 2024); the state covers the rest.
What keeps going
The normal cost, the price of benefits current staff earn each year: $0.83 billion for FY2028 (8.45% of pension payroll). The retirement board's funding policy keeps it in place until the plan is 120% funded. Whether districts or the state keep the freed-up debt money is a budget decision lawmakers haven't made.
Ahead of peers, behind its own benchmark
The release credits “strong investment stewardship.” Against other large public pensions, the fund has done well. Against the benchmark its own board sets (a blend of indexes matching its target mix), it trailed in every period. Much of the gain came from strong markets.
| Annualized, as of Dec. 31, 2025 | 1 yr | 3 yr | 5 yr | 7 yr | 10 yr |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| State of Michigan Retirement Systems | 13.7% | 11.5% | 9.7% | 10.7% | 10.1% |
| Its own policy benchmark | 15.3% | 14.7% | 10.1% | 11.1% | 10.5% |
| Peer median (public plans over $10B) | 13.6% | 11.8% | 8.6% | 10.1% | 9.0% |
Source: State of Michigan Investment Board, Executive Summary, March 25, 2026, slide 2 (peer universe: State Street, public funds over $10 billion). The same slide credits beating the median with “approximately $15 billion in excess value” over ten years. For MPSERS alone in FY2025, private equity returned 6.4% against its 18.6% benchmark (S&P 500 plus 3 points, lagged a quarter), per the FY2025 annual report, p. 74.
A pooled $122 billion, nearly half in private assets
MPSERS doesn't hold securities in its own name. Its money (about $94 billion with retiree health) is pooled with the state employees', state police and judges' systems and managed by Treasury's Bureau of Investments. Three public sources show what's inside.
Show as a table
| Asset class | Share | Pricing |
|---|---|---|
| U.S. stocks | 21.1% | Public |
| Private equity | 20.4% | Private |
| International stocks | 15.5% | Public |
| Bonds (fixed income) | 11.8% | Public |
| Hedge funds (absolute return) | 10.1% | Private |
| Real return & opportunistic | 8.8% | Private |
| Real estate & infrastructure | 7.9% | Private |
| Cash (short term) | 4.4% | Public |
Show as a table
| Holding | Value | Share of 13F |
|---|
Other places to look
The MPSERS annual report (Investment Section) lists MPSERS's top 10 stocks and top 10 bonds. On Sept. 30, 2025 the stocks were led by Nvidia, Microsoft, Apple, Amazon and Meta, and the bonds were mostly U.S. Treasuries. It says “a complete list of stock and bond holdings is available from the Michigan Department of Treasury,” so the full list is available on request. The Investment Board's quarterly reports break down each asset class, including private-equity and real-estate managers.
Announced two weeks after the election, ahead of the official numbers
The release didn't reveal anything that was being held back: the early-payoff forecast had been public since January 2025. But it arrived before the Investment Board has reviewed the year's results and months before the actuaries measure the plan again. It also makes a policy request of whoever governs next.
- Jul. 13, 2017PA 92 of 2017 signed: the debt payment can't fall below the prior year's until the debt is paid off. PA 181 of 2018 later made that a dollar floor.
- FY2023One-time extra deposits of $1 billion plus $140 million into MPSERS.
- 2024PA 127 of 2024: districts' cap drops from 20.96% to 15.21% of payroll; retiree-health contribution floors end. PA 120 of 2024 adds $250 million for FY2025.
- Jan. 2025Treasury's asset-liability study (Aon): full funding expected by fiscal 2031 in the central case.
- Mar. 3, 2026Sept. 30, 2025 valuation issued: 74.6% funded.
- Mar. 25, 2026Chief Investment Officer to the Investment Board: “For every year sooner the Funds become fully funded, a projected $3.5 billion is added to the budget annually.”
- Jul. 21, 2026FY2027 budget signed. The retirees' association MARSP writes that the state “remains on track to pay off all pension debt by 2035.”
- Sep. 30, 2026State fiscal year 2026 ends.
- Nov. 3, 2026Election Day. The Governor is term-limited.
- Nov. 17, 2026The release: “on track to reach full funding by 2030.”
- Dec. 16, 2026Investment Board meets; fiscal 2026 results expected.
- Jan. 2027New governor and Legislature take office; the FY2028 budget follows.
- Spring 2027Sept. 30, 2026 valuation expected: the first official measure of the claim.
The request in the release
“Future gubernatorial administrations and legislatures will need to work together to ensure the pension system reaches full funding but is not overfunded. Overpayments into the trust will result in a loss of dollars that could be used in the classroom.”Governor's release, Nov. 17, 2026
The case for stopping at 100%
If payments simply continue, Treasury's own study projected a median funded ratio of 154% by 2043. Money beyond what's needed sits in the trust instead of classrooms.
The case for a cushion
At exactly 100%, one bad market year puts the plan back under water. The retirement board's own policy keeps normal-cost payments in place until the plan is 120% funded, and Treasury's study put a bad-markets case (1 in 20) at 59% in 2033.
For Troy, about $15 million a year, if the state lets districts keep it
Every district pays a charge toward the MPSERS debt. Since October 2025 it has been 15.21% of payroll. When the debt is paid off, that charge ends. At Troy's current payroll, that's about $14.8 million a year, if the state passes it through instead of offsetting it, which it hasn't always done.
Troy's MPSERS bill, 2025–26 school year
| From Troy's FY2026 audit | Amount | Share of covered payroll |
|---|---|---|
| Pension contributions (incl. defined-contribution members) | $38,592,217 | 39.7% |
| of which state money passed straight through (Section 147c) | $13,805,287 | 14.2% |
| Retiree-health contributions | $3,050,751 | 3.1% |
| Paid from Troy's own budget (our calculation) | $27,837,681 | 28.6% |
| Covered payroll | $97,218,696 | |
| General fund spending / change in fund balance | $202,195,371 / −$2,385,591 |
Source: Troy School District FY2026 audited financial statements (presented Nov. 10, 2026), pension and OPEB notes, required supplementary information and general fund statement. The 147c pass-through is booked as both revenue and expense, so when it ends, it has no effect on Troy's bottom line.
How big $14.8M is for Troy
- 7.3% of 2025–26 general fund spending ($202.2M).
- About 2.4–2.5 times the deficits in Troy's February 2026 four-year forecast.
- About 1.2 times the board's “$12 million in reductions” target (March 2026).
- Cross-check: Troy's share of MPSERS (0.85944%) × the release's $1.7B district share = $14.6M.
When it would arrive
Not before the 2030–31 school year, and only if “2030” means the last debt payment. If it means a valuation date, the relief could come around 2032–33, because valuations set rates about three years out. Troy's four-year forecast ends in 2028–29 and has no MPSERS line, so this money doesn't help the deficits the board is cutting for now.
The last two rounds of “relief”
Troy's own documents show why the $14.8M isn't guaranteed. The state has reshaped MPSERS savings before:
- 2024–25: the $598 million the state redirected to schools reached Troy as a one-time payment of $5,055,278. Troy's administration called it “Essentially one-time money” (budget presentation, Jan. 20, 2026). Troy's audited report said the state gave it “rather than a traditional increase to the foundation allowance.”
- 2025–26: the debt charge dropped from 20.96% to 15.21% of payroll. That one-time payment ended, and other state offsets changed. Troy raised its retirement budget by $3,612,635 for “unanticipated increases in employer contribution rates.” Its January 2026 planning deck put it this way: “Retirement and health-care costs once covered by State have been shifted to the employer.”
- Net effect (our calculation): after subtracting the state's MPSERS offsets, Troy's own MPSERS cost was 27.24% of payroll in 2024–25 and 27.27% in 2025–26, essentially unchanged. One 2024–25 offset (Section 147a(1)) wasn't found and isn't counted.
Sources: Troy School District FY2023–FY2026 audits and Plante Moran management letters; budget presentations of Jan. 13 and Jan. 20, 2026; “TSD – 4-Year General Fund Forecast, February 2026” (Mar. 7, 2026 retreat); Budget Amendment 2 (Mar. 17, 2026). All are in the public Troy board document archive. No Troy document mentions 2038, the payoff date, or pension full funding.
Questions the release leaves open
- What assumptions produce 2030: which returns, what contributions, and on the smoothed or market-value basis?
- Does “2030” mean the last debt payment, or the valuation date that shows full funding? Valuations set rates about three years out, so the answer moves the savings by up to three years.
- Is the $3.2 billion the floored debt payment, and how exactly is it split between the state and districts?
- Will the board's 120% funding target stay in place, or does “not overfunded” mean stopping at 100%?
- When the debt payment ends, does the districts' $1.7 billion stay with districts, or will the state recapture it through school aid?
- Will Treasury publish the complete holdings list its annual report says is available?
Every document used
Copies of each source, the 13F parsing script and a figure-by-figure source log are in the public repository.
- Office of the Governor, press release, Nov. 17, 2026
- MPSERS pension actuarial valuation as of Sept. 30, 2025 (issued Mar. 3, 2026), plus the 2024 and 2023 valuations
- MPSERS retiree-health (OPEB) valuation as of Sept. 30, 2025
- MPSERS Annual Comprehensive Financial Report, FY2025
- Aon, MPSERS Asset-Liability Study, January 2025
- State of Michigan Investment Board, Executive Summary, Mar. 25, 2026
- State of Michigan Retirement System, SEC Form 13F filings (CIK 762152)
- MARSP, “Michigan FY 2027 Budget Keeps MPSERS Funding on Track,” July 2026
- Troy School District: FY2026 audit, FY2025 management letter, Jan. 20, 2026 budget presentation, 4-year forecast (Feb. 2026), and the rest of the board document archive
- Bridge Michigan, “Whitmer seeks $670M for Michigan schools. Critics call it a ‘raid’” and Reason Foundation's backgrounder on the 2024 change